Reviews & Ratings for Cicero's Pizza

04/18/11

Awesome

by belida at Citysearch

Pizza can be hit or miss for me. I just don't eat much of it. I have to say I really liked Ciceros and my choice to go their was based on the good reviews

Cicero serves great thin crust which is the only pizza I like. Typically the thin crust is too crunchy but the crust was crisp on the edges and a little doughy in the middle. I loved it!

Cost for two is about $15 which included drinks. This was for two mediums. I was full but not stuffed so you may want to get a large and a medium for heavy eaters that can't get enough.

09/22/07

By far the BEST pizza I have ever sank my teeth into!

by sweet75ca at Citysearch

I absolutely LOVE this pizza! It is a flake-y, buttery taste of heaven that having anymore than the traditional cheese pizza would ruin the whole Cicero's experience! This place really does have the secret! As busy as it gets, the facility is always clean and the service is very good. It is large enough to hold many groups, and is a great place for children. Most importantly, It is run by family, and for that I am proud to support and provide my business to. I hope that they keep the family tradition moving strong for a very long time. Plus, it would be great to see them expand to another city. They should have taken the #1 slot for 'best of' ...HANDS DOWN!!!

• Pros: Great Food, Clean, Affordable
• Cons: None

07/09/07

I don't get it

by gubners55 at Citysearch

Based on all the great reviews here, we tried it for lunch one day. A couple different medium combos. We found the crust ok, but the flavor just wasn't there. The toppings are little crumbs of meat products lightly scattered on top and not enough cheese. We found it dry and bland. It most resembles Baron pizza that we find in the freezer at our local Safeway. Sorry, but if you think this is great stuff, you need to get out more.

• Pros: easy strip mall parking
• Cons: Better pizza next door in the grocery store's frozen section

Editorial Review by Christy Buena

by Contributor at Citysearch

Restaurant serves fresh pizzas prepared daily and offers a selection of toppings, salads and offers merchandise including T-shirts.

11/02/06

Not Bad

by blurooster at Citysearch

The pizza isn't fantastic, but it beats going to a large number of places in the Bay Area. Be prepared for extra grease though...

09/08/06

I love this place!

by dfdesign at Citysearch

Amazing thin crust pizza. my roommate carol introduced me to this place when i moved out here. I'm from the east coast and had been complaining that CA suxs for pizza and bagels.... i'm right... but Cicero is the best CA has to offer and I have no complaints when i eat their belly buster.... ooo its good!

02/17/06

The Best Thin Crust Pizza Ever!

by tita1075 at Citysearch

I heard of this pizza place through a friend and was instantly a fan. Its the best pizza I have ever had in my life!! Every person I have told has said the same thing after trying it.

• Pros: Great Taste, Thin Crust
• Cons: A Little expensive

08/24/05

Does Not Get Better!

by piedujour at Citysearch

I have only lived in the Bay Area for 6 years and have just now discovered Cicero's.

It was EXACTLY what I've been looking for. I was so tired of all these pizza chains. Now I've found my new pizza place forever! I simply can't get enough of that buttery thin crispy crust and that cheese and secret sauce! Wow!

I'm so surprised that there are actually people out there dissing Cicero's! I am taking it personal.

• Pros: the best pizza EVER, that sauce, that crust

06/12/05

One of the best Pizzas I have ever tasted

by lisahazarika at Citysearch

Wow! that the exact word I said when I gulped my first bite. Love the pizzas, the crust is perfect and all together it melts in your mouth! Two Thumbs up for this cozy place.

• Pros: Pizzas, Fast
• Cons: Restrooms